Can AI Generate the Same Painting Twice? A Probability Perspective

AI art, digital painting, futuristic portrait, surreal eyes, artificial intelligence, cybernetic vision, abstract realism, neural art, technology and creativity, machine-generated art
AI and the Evolution of Creativity
February 15, 2017
"Hello, world!" text on a textured beige background, with a colorful explosion of doodles, symbols, and abstract shapes emerging from a central "AI" key, representing creativity and artificial intelligence.
From “Hello, World!” to AI Art: The Endless Loop of Creativity
February 10, 2025

Can AI Generate the Same Painting Twice? A Probability Perspective

AI art generators create images based on mathematical models trained on vast datasets. But can two users get exactly the same painting? The answer lies in probability, randomness, and high-dimensional spaces.

How AI Generates Images:
Most AI art tools, like diffusion models or GANs, introduce randomness in the creation process. This means every time you generate an image, the output is slightly different—even with the same prompt.

Probability Analysis:
Let's consider an AI model that generates 1024x1024 pixel images with 256 possible colors per pixel. The total number of possible images is:

256^(1024×1024)

This is an unimaginably large number—far more than the number of atoms in the universe! The chance of generating the exact same image twice (randomly) is practically zero.

Controlled Reproducibility:
Some AI models allow users to set a seed number—a fixed starting point for randomization. If two users use the exact same prompt, model version, and seed, they might get identical images. However, most people don’t use this option, making duplicates extremely rare.

Example Experiment:

  1. Use an AI tool like DALL·E or Stable Diffusion.
  2. Enter the same prompt multiple times (e.g., “A futuristic city at sunset”).
  3. Compare the outputs—they will likely be similar but never identical.
  4. Now, set a fixed seed value and generate again—you should see a perfect duplicate.

Due to the immense number of possible images and the randomness in AI, the probability of generating the exact same artwork for different users is nearly zero. Only under specific conditions (fixed seed and controlled inputs) can an AI replicate an image perfectly.

 

Here is an AI-generated image of a futuristic city at sunset.

Here is another AI-generated image using the same prompt but with a different seed.
March 21, 2025
A digital painting of an 18th-century nobleman in ornate brown and gold attire, with a calm expression and powdered wig. The right side of the portrait is overlaid with lines of computer code, blending into his face and coat, symbolizing the fusion of classical portraiture with artificial intelligence.
Can AI Art Reclaim Edmond de Belamy’s Glory?
The Million-Dollar Algorithm: Can AI Art Reclaim Edmond de Belamy's Glory? In 2018, the art world held its breath as "Edmond de Belamy," a portrait generated by an artificial intelligence, sold for a staggering $432,500 at Christie's.
February 15, 2017
AI art, digital painting, futuristic portrait, surreal eyes, artificial intelligence, cybernetic vision, abstract realism, neural art, technology and creativity, machine-generated art
AI and the Evolution of Creativity
In today's world, AI is revolutionizing art. Artists once prepared canvases and paints, pouring their passion into each brushstroke. Now, with AI, creating art can be as simple as describing your vision.
image_fx_ (54)
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. By using this website you agree to our Data Protection Policy.
Read more